Pension Savings vs IRP vs ISA — Which Account Should You Start With First?

Read in Korean → 한국어로 읽기

In Part 1, we looked at why pension savings accounts form the core of long-term wealth.
But many people still feel confused when they see similar account names.

I felt the same way at first.

Pension savings?
IRP?
ISA?

Let’s break down these three most commonly compared accounts — clearly and simply.

---

🔎 Quick Comparison Table

Category	Pension Savings	IRP	ISA
Main Purpose	Retirement + tax credit	Retirement + enhanced tax credit	Mid–long-term tax-efficient investing
Tax Credit	✅ Yes	✅ Yes	❌ No
Investable Assets	ETFs, funds	ETFs (more restrictions)	ETFs, stocks, deposits, bonds
Early Withdrawal	Limited	Very restricted	Allowed
Withdrawal Tax	Pension income tax 3.3–5.5%	Same	Gains tax-free (within limits)
Flexibility	Medium	Low	Very high

---

1️⃣ Pension Savings — Balanced Account for Tax + Growth

• Annual tax credit benefits
• ETF investing available
• Low withdrawal tax (3.3–5.5%)
• Limited early withdrawal

👉 Key message: “Tax benefits + compounding growth — the most balanced long-term account.”

👉 Related Reading: [Why a Pension Savings Account Matters — The First Account That Builds Long-Term Wealth]

---

2️⃣ IRP — Stronger Tax Credit, Lower Flexibility

• Higher tax credit limit than pension savings
• Much stricter investment choices
• Severe penalties for early withdrawal

For example:

• Overseas ETFs may be restricted
• Individual stock investing is limited
• Liquidity is very low

👉 Key message: “If you focus only on tax credits, IRP can feel restrictive later.”

---

3️⃣ ISA — Maximum Flexibility + Tax-Free Gains

Among the three, ISA is the most flexible.

• Invest in stocks, ETFs, deposits, bonds
• Gains tax-free up to a certain limit
• Excess gains taxed at a reduced rate
• Withdraw anytime without penalty

👉 Key message: “Growth + flexibility — ideal for beginner to intermediate investors.”

👉 Related Reading: [5 Steps for Automatic ETF Investing — Build Wealth Without Emotional Decisions]

---

✨ Which Account Should You Start With?

The answer is simpler than it looks.

If you qualify for tax credits,
start with pension savings first.

✅ Recommended Order

1. Pension Savings
2. ISA
3. IRP (optional)

This order is based on two principles:

• Tax efficiency → locks in higher returns
• Flexibility → helps you stay invested long-term

In short:

“Pension savings builds the base → ISA drives growth → IRP is optional.”

---

🧩 How Wealthy Investors Structure Their Accounts

A commonly observed structure:

1. Pension Savings ETFs — annual base contributions
2. ISA — expanded investment opportunities
3. IRP — used only when extra tax credit is needed

This combination balances:

• Long-term growth
• Liquidity
• Tax efficiency

All three accounts are useful —
but the order matters more than the existence.

👉 Related Reading: [How to Automate Your Savings: 5 Steps to Make Money Grow on Its Own]

---

✨ Final Thoughts

Pension savings, IRP, and ISA
are all important tools in a long-term wealth loop.

But they are not interchangeable,
despite their similar names.

Choosing which account comes first
can easily create a major asset gap
over the next 10–20 years.

Start with the account that fits your current financial structure best.

In the next article, we’ll go deeper into:

• How to choose ETFs inside a pension savings account
• Practical portfolio examples
• Mistakes beginners often make

That’s where execution really begins.